How do the inclusion of images in the creation story affect one's reading of it?
The inclusion of images in the telling of a story alters the
perceptions of the reader and can lead to two different interpretations of the
same story. R. Crumb’s comic version of The
Book of Genesis, and The Manga Bible:
From Genesis to Revelation, present the story of creation in comic form. R.
Crumb’s version is much more specific in his depictions of the story while
illustrator Siku’s comic gives various images in each panel rather than a
complete scene. Looking at each comic’s illustration of Adam naming the animals
of the world shows the different styles of the two works. Panel 13 of chapter 2
in R. Crumb’s comic shows Adam, clearly in the Garden of Eden, naming a bear.
In Panel 19 of Siku’s comic, Adam names animals as they line up in front of him
in an ambiguous location. Crumb looks at the story on micro level, while Siku
looks at it on a more macro one. Crumb’s detailed drawings show specific
snapshots from the story, leaving less up to the reader’s imagination and
making each person’s interpretation relatively similar to one another’s. Siku’s
drawings depict the story with various images from a series of events appearing
on a single panel. This approach allows the reader to fill in the gaps themselves,
leading to a wider variety of experiences for each person who views the comic. The Book of Genesis illustrated by R.
Crumb and The Manga Bible: From Genesis to
Revelation show the creation story in two very different comic forms that
affect the reader’s experience.
No comments:
Post a Comment